The Journaling Question That Gets You Past the Surface Emotion

There's a specific kind of betrayal that only happens on paper, Reader.

You sit down to write about your day. You're grumpy, and you're pretty sure you know why you're grumpy, and you start explaining it to the page in reasonable, well-organized (adult!) sentences.

And then somewhere around the third paragraph, your own hand writes something you did not authorize.

Mine wrote this, about a job I had spent years wanting: this was your dream job. It isn't what you want.

I sat there and stared at it. In my own handwriting — which is so much worse, somehow, because you cannot argue that somebody else said it.

I'd been telling everybody I was just tired. I'd been telling myself it was a rough stretch, a bad quarter, a phase that would pass. And the page skipped all of that and put the actual sentence down where I had to look at it.

Here's what was really happening — and there's a better explanation than "the journal is magic."

I call it the leaky faucet.

For weeks I'd been complaining about the drip.

Every entry: I'm annoyed, I'm exhausted, that person was short with me, that meeting ran long.

Drip, drip, drip.

I'd name the feeling "angry," feel briefly better, and move on. Then do it again the next day.

But nobody's actually angry at a drip. You're angry that nobody's fixed the faucet. Underneath all those small daily irritations sat one big unresolved thing I hadn't looked at directly in months.

Writing it down every day is the only reason I ever saw it clearly. Any single entry looked like a bad day. Twenty of them stacked up...was a pattern.

The page isn't psychic. It's just the only place in your life that keeps a receipt.

Your one small thing this week.

Next time you finish an entry, don't close the notebook yet.

Go back and underline the emotion you named — angry, tired, fine, stressed, whatever word you grabbed for.

Then write one more line underneath it: Is that actually it?

And answer honestly. Three more sentences, that's all. It is genuinely startling how often the real answer has been sitting one layer down the whole time, waiting for somebody to ask it a direct question.

Then hit reply and tell me: what has the page told you that you weren't ready to hear? A job, a friendship, a habit, a story you'd been telling about yourself for years. I already went first up there, so you're covered.

Deep breaths. Just write.

Krystal

​
​

P.S. This is why I'm a little suspicious of advice to only journal about the good things. Gratitude lists are wonderful, and I keep one. They will also never, not once, tell you to quit your job.

P.P.S. Have you grabbed my 5 favorite starter prompts yet? These are my go-to prompts I use when I just don't know what to write about. Grab them for free here (it's a Google Drive link).